Tatem Insurance puts building strong relationships with our customers at the top of our to-do list. That means you’re not just a name and policy to us. We get to know you. We find out what your goals are. And we really assess your situation to make sure you get the best coverage, premiums and discounts for you.

We also have a long history of providing the best insurance coverage possible to protect you, your loved ones and your possessions. Founded in 1958, Tatem Insurance set up roots in Vincennes. Since then, the agency has grown in size and in location. We now have agents based in historic downtown Vincennes and Indianapolis, all focused on serving you.

What makes Tatem better?
First and foremost, when you call Tatem, you’ll always talk to a real person. Our experienced, licensed insurance agents answer the phone. No confusing automated recordings. No impersonal connections.

Second, Tatem is an independent insurance agency. As such, we have access to numerous top-rated insurance companies. That puts us in a unique position to help you get the most out of your insurance. We’re able to shop different plans from different companies to find the right products and services for your situation. (It’s also what makes us vastly different than those online insurance giants). Whether you’re a family looking for great personal insurance or a business that want to make sure your investment and employees are protected, Tatem has you covered.

Rest easy in knowing you’re getting a good insurance product, though. Tatem holds the companies we represent to the highest standards and constantly monitors their performance to ensure you get the best possible service. We’re also always looking at new companies that may be an asset to your personal or business security.

What can you expect from your Tatem Insurance team?
Tatem works for you, not the insurance company. We make it a priority to show you know who we are, what we offer, and how we will help secure the home, business, or other assets you have worked so hard to obtain.

From your very first meeting with us, you’ll notice our insurance professionals are different (in the best kind of way). Our first order of business will be to examine what your present and future needs will be. From there, we’ll get to work and develop an effective, well-rounded insurance program that fits you, your family or your business and will withstand time. But it’s not a one and done meeting. Life continually changes, and your insurance needs to reflect that. We’ll continue to evaluate your coverage requirements and make recommendations on what is the best program for you.

You’ve come to the right place.
We keep it real and simple.

Download our free service app.

We provide 24/7 Customer Service and secure access to all your insurance information. Don’t worry, you can also call us at 1-800-737-3600 if you have any questions or need a username and password.

  • View Policy Information
  • Request Changes to Your Contact Information
  • Generate Auto ID Cards
  • Request Policy Changes
  • Report a Claim